⛵ Ready to take the trip of a lifetime? I write a twice monthly, free newsletter with planning ideas for your next yacht charter trip: insider destination guides, sailing itineraries, and the latest news.
Share
⛵🏴☠️ Pirate Havens of the British Virgin Islands
Published over 1 year ago • 3 min read
Hi Reader,
Before we hoist sails on today's journey, let's navigate through a couple of recent news items:
Last week the Baths bore witness to a charter grounding on the rocks amidst Red Flag conditions. This incident mirrors the lee shore grounding of the Hillbilly a few weeks ago. Takeaways: monitor weather resources vigilantly, respect Red Flag warnings, and steer clear of anchorages that test fate (lee shores).
There have been recent reports of multiple stolen dinghies at JVD, BVI. Raise your dinghy on davits if you can, and utilize your dinghy lock at night.
Meanwhile, Lagoon announced their new Lagoon 43, which will begin to replace the 42 in charter fleets over the next few years as they come into production. Key changes include: the addition of a seated flybridge area and some modular components, such as table layouts which connect the indoor and outdoor space.
Today's newsletter serves as a treasure map to the rich historical tapestry of the BVI, offering a glimpse into the turbulent waters of the past. As we prepare to dive deeper into each story in the coming weeks, consider this a preview of tales and treachery that colored the British Virgin Islands (BVI) during the golden age of piracy.
These islands were not just idyllic paradises but pivotal stages for the drama of piracy to unfold, with each cove and island holding stories of hidden treasures and pirate escapades.
Norman Island, one of the sites of rich Pirate lore
A Deeper Dive into Pirate History in the BVI
The BVI’s intricate network of over 50 islands and cays, with their secluded bays and hidden nooks, made them a natural sanctuary for pirates seeking refuge and a strategic lookout for unsuspecting merchant ships.
The 17th and 18th centuries saw these waters teem with pirate ships, their sails on the horizon striking fear into the hearts of sailors. As European powers vied for control of the Caribbean, the ensuing chaos provided a perfect backdrop for pirates like Henry Morgan to ply their trade, weaving their names into the fabric of maritime legend.
The Caves at Norman Island
Norman Island: Unveiling the Treasure Myth
Norman Island is steeped in tales of buried pirate treasures, drawing a direct line to the piracy era. Allegedly the inspiration for Robert Louis Stevenson's "Treasure Island," it's rumored that pirates once hid their loot in the island's numerous caves.
This tangible connection to piracy's treasure-hunting ventures makes Norman Island a focal point for those seeking to unravel the mysteries of the past, where fact and folklore merge beneath the Caribbean sun.
Deadman's Bay and Dead Chest Island in the background
The Myth of Blackbeard and Dead Chest Island
The legend of Blackbeard, or Edward Teach, is intrinsically linked to the BVI, particularly Dead Chest Island. Folklore has it that Blackbeard marooned fifteen of his men here with only a bottle of rum, giving rise to the song "Fifteen Men on a Dead Man's Chest."
While academic evidence might not pinpoint Blackbeard's presence in the BVI, the lore surrounding Dead Chest Island embodies the perilous life of pirates and the brutal reality of their brotherhood.
White Bay, Jost Van Dyke
Jost Van Dyke: Reveling in Pirate Camaraderie
Jost Van Dyke embodies the spirit of freedom and festivity often associated with pirate lore. The island's namesake, a Dutch pirate, would be pleased to see his legacy of liberty live on in the island’s lively beach bars and welcoming atmosphere.
The famous Foxy’s and the Soggy Dollar Bar are not just places to enjoy a drink; they are modern-day meeting places where tales of adventure are exchanged, much like the pirates of old might have shared their own stories. Jost Van Dyke is a testament to the enduring allure of the Caribbean’s pirate past, wrapped in the warmth of island hospitality.
Setting Point Anegada
Anegada: Among the Ghosts of Shipwrecks
Anegada, with its dangerous reefs and shallow waters, stands as a silent guardian over countless shipwrecks, each with its own story of misfortune. Diving into the clear waters to explore wrecks like the Donna Paula, a merchant ship that met its fate in the 19th century, offers a tangible connection to the maritime history that shapes the BVI. Another one is the HMS Astraea that was on escort duty to protect against pirates.
These underwater graveyards serve as a reminder of the perils that awaited those who navigated these waters, from pirates to sailors, and the fine line between fortune and folly.
The Jolly Roger flying at Setting Point Anegada
Charting a Course Through History
As we dive into the BVI's piracy history in the coming weeks, each island will connect us directly to the age of adventure. These stories, blending historical facts with legendary tales, will offer a richer backdrop for your next charter visit.
That's it for today!
Have a great week!
- Matt Weidert
Get a free Soggy Painkiller, on us!
Have friends who'd love our newsletter too? Give them your unique referral link (below). When 3 people subscribe, we'll put a painkiller on the Soggy Dollar Bar Drink Board for you. It never expires.
⛵ Ready to take the trip of a lifetime? I write a twice monthly, free newsletter with planning ideas for your next yacht charter trip: insider destination guides, sailing itineraries, and the latest news.
Hi Reader, Emilia here with some fresh impressions straight from the BVI and USVI yacht shows—literally just two weeks old. I spent days stepping aboard yachts, meeting crews, and capturing insights you won’t find in any brochure. And for your weekend reading, I’ve pulled together the standouts—the yachts that genuinely rose above the rest. Whether you're planning your first charter or your tenth, think of this as a quick hit of inspiration for wherever your next trip takes you. These are the...
Hi Reader, Let me take you somewhere special today. Somewhere flat as a pancake, fringed uninterrupted pink sand beaches, rimmed in impossible shades of turquoise, and humming with that slow, sweet rhythm you only find far from the crowds. Anegada. Spectacular pink sand beaches await A frequent question I get from BVI guests — crewed and bareboat alike — is: “Should we go to Anegada?” And my answer is almost always an unequivocal yes. It’s one of my favorite places in all of the Virgin...
Hi Reader, I'm just back from an incredible week at the USVI and BVI charter yacht shows. The Yacht Warriors team spent the days catching up with familiar faces, meeting standout new crews, and stepping aboard more than 100 yachts to see what’s new for the 2025–2026 season. Check out this quick recap reel on my Instagram to check in on some of the past week's action! There’s always a bit shifting beneath the surface in this industry—and trust me, this year was no exception. If you’re...