Hi Reader,

In case you missed it, I wrote last time about exploring a charter in French Polynesia for my 40th coming up next year.

This week, let's compare Tahiti to a destination most of us already familiar, the BVI. Both destinations offer unique experiences, each with its own charm and challenges. So, let's see how an adventure to the Society Islands stacks up.

But first, a couple quick notes:

• If you're chartering in BVI over the next few months, check out our list of bars and restaurants that are temporarily closing for hurricane season. We do our best to keep this updated each year. Feel free to let us know if we missed anything.

• A 74 ft private catamaran is still on the reef at Flamenco Beach in the Spanish Virgin Islands after grounding back on July 21st. The USCG is assisting, but it's unclear when salvage operations will be completed.

Scenery and Environment: BVI vs Tahiti

When it comes to sheer beauty, both the BVI and French Polynesia are nothing short of spectacular, yet they offer very different vibes. The BVI, an archipelago of over 60 islands, is a haven for those seeking pristine beaches, lush landscapes, and a relaxed atmosphere. Imagine gentle rolling hills blanketed in green, set against a backdrop of crystal-clear waters. The scenery here is serene and invites you to unwind and let the laid-back island vibes wash over you.

Now, let’s sail over to French Polynesia, where the scenery doesn’t just whisper—it sings! The dramatic landscapes here are dominated by towering volcanic peaks and stunning lagoons that are a feast for the eyes. Picture this: lush, jagged mountains rising majestically from turquoise waters, surrounded by coral gardens that are home to manta rays, sharks, and an array of vibrant fish. It’s a place where nature’s grandeur is on full display, leaving you in awe at every anchorage.

Sailing Conditions

For those who love the thrill of the wind in their sails, the BVI offers some of the most consistent and manageable sailing conditions. The trade winds here typically range between 10-25 knots, providing a gentle push that’s perfect for sailors of all levels. Navigation is a breeze, thanks to well-marked channels and line-of-sight sailing between the islands. With numerous protected anchorages and plenty of mooring balls, finding a safe and comfortable spot for the night is a breeze.

In contrast, French Polynesia is for the more adventurous sailor. The trade winds are stronger, often blowing between 15-25 knots, and the navigation is more challenging due to the intricate lagoons and coral heads. Navigating these waters requires keen attention and skill, especially when dealing with the ocean swells that can add an exhilarating edge to your journey. The passages between islands can be longer and more exposed, making each leg of the journey feel like a true adventure. If you’re up for a challenge and crave the excitement of more demanding sailing, French Polynesia will not disappoint.

Cultural Experience: Caribbean Charm vs Polynesian Heritage

Cultural immersion is one of the joys of sailing, and both the BVI and French Polynesia offer rich, albeit different, experiences. The BVI exudes a laid-back Caribbean vibe with a delightful mix of British and local influences. Think beach bars where you can kick back with a rum punch, savor local dishes like conch fritters, and enjoy live music that gets your toes tapping. Iconic spots like Foxy’s on Jost Van Dyke and The Soggy Dollar Bar are must-visits, offering a taste of the Caribbean party scene.

French Polynesia, on the other hand, immerses you in a rich tapestry of Polynesian culture. The locals, known for their warmth and hospitality, will welcome you with open arms. Here, you can experience traditional ceremonies, vibrant dance performances, and intricate art. Visiting ancient marae (temples) and traditional villages adds a cultural depth to your adventure that’s truly enriching. The sense of history and tradition is palpable, making every interaction a meaningful part of your journey.

Accessibility and Logistics

Getting to your sailing destination and managing logistics can significantly impact your overall experience. The BVI scores moderately high on accessibility, especially for those traveling from the US and Europe. Flights into Beef Island (EIS) are frequent and typically involve a brief layover in nearby hubs like San Juan or St. Thomas. Increased direct flights from Miami are making this even easier. Once you arrive, provisioning is straightforward with well-stocked supermarkets and convenient delivery services, ensuring you can easily gather everything you need for your voyage.

Reaching French Polynesia is more of an odyssey. Long-haul flights to Tahiti (PPT) are usually followed by a domestic connection to Raiatea where the charter bases are located. The journey is longer and requires more planning, but the reward is a sense of adventure and exclusivity. Provisioning here can be more challenging and expensive, so it’s wise to pre-order supplies through your charter company. The remote location adds a thrilling element to your trip but also means you’ll need to be more self-sufficient and prepared.

Cost: Chartering in the BVI vs Tahiti

Budget considerations are always important, and here’s where the BVI and French Polynesia diverge. The BVI offers a range of charter options from budget-friendly to luxurious, making it accessible to a broader audience. Dining and activities are reasonably priced, although exclusive spots can still be a bit of a splurge. Overall, the BVI provides excellent value for money, making it a popular choice for many sailors.

French Polynesia, however, tends to be on the pricier side. The remoteness and higher operating costs are reflected in the charter prices, dining, and activities. Everything from a meal at a local restaurant to a guided tour can be significantly more expensive compared to the BVI. This higher cost often translates into a more exclusive and intimate experience, perfect for those looking to splurge on a truly unforgettable adventure.

Conclusion: Embracing the Best of Both Worlds

So, when it comes to choosing between the BVI and Tahiti, it doesn’t have to be an either-or decision. Each destination offers its own unique magic. The BVI, with its consistent sailing conditions, vibrant beach bars, and accessible logistics, is perfect for an annual trip where relaxation and familiarity reign supreme. It's an ideal spot for seasoned sailors and newcomers alike to enjoy the Caribbean charm without too many surprises.

On the other hand, Tahiti presents an opportunity for a grand adventure. Although I haven’t experienced it myself yet, the dramatic landscapes, rich Polynesian culture, and more challenging sailing conditions make it a dream for those looking to celebrate a special occasion or to mix things up. Based on everything I've learned, it seems like the perfect destination for a milestone event or a unique, once-in-a-lifetime trip.

Ultimately, the choice isn’t about picking one over the other but rather about understanding what kind of experience you’re yearning for. Whether it’s the comforting embrace of the Caribbean or the thrilling allure of Polynesia, each offers something extraordinary.

Have a great week! - Matt Weidert